Notice: this is a new page to replace the legacy Great Lakes Water Life gallery. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact Rochelle Sturtevant at rochelle.sturtevant@noaa.gov

Field Guide - Aquatic Insects of the Great Lakes

Contents:

This Field Guide is based on information from:

Lehmkuhl, D.M. 1979. how to know the aquatic insects. The Pictured Key Nature Series. Wm C. Brown Co. Dubuque, Iowa.

American Museum of Natural History Key to Insect Orders. https://www.amnh.org/learn/biodiversity_counts/ident_help/Text_Keys/arthropod_keyA.htm Accessed 2008.

Valley City State University. Digital Key to Aquatic Insects of North Dakota. http://www.waterbugkey.vcsu.edu/php/mainkey.php?id=Order3 Accessed 2008.

NOAA. Great Lakes Aquatic Nonindigenous Species Information System (GLANSIS). https://www.glerl.noaa.gov/glansis/ Accessed 2019.

Additional guides and keys:

Cudmore-Vokey, B., Crossman, E.J. 2000. Checklists of the fish fauna of the Laurentian Great Lakes and their connecting channels. Can. Ms. Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci., no. 2550.

Roth, B.M., Mandrak, N.E., Hrabik, T.H., Sass, G.G., Peters, J. 2012. Fishes and decapod crustaceans of the Great Lakes Basin. In Taylor, W.W., Lynch, A. (Eds.), Great Lakes Policy and Management: A Binational Perspective, Michigan State University Press, East Lansing, Michigan, pp. 105–136.

Balcer, M.D., Korda, N.L., Dodson, S.I. 1984. Zooplankton of the Great Lakes: A guide to the identification and ecology of the common Crustacean species. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison Wisconsin. Balcer part 1, Balcer part 2, Balcer part 3

Grothe, D.W., Grothe, D.R. 1977. An Illustrated Key to the Planktonic Rotifers of the Laurentian Great Lakes. U.S. EPA, Great Lakes National Program Office, Chicago, Illinois.

Hudson, P.L., Lesko, L.T., 2003. Free-living and Parasitic Copepods of the Laurentian Great Lakes: Keys and Details on Individual Species. Available at https://www.glsc.usgs.gov/greatlakescopepods/MainMenu.php.

Robertson, A., Gannon, J. E. 1981. Annotated checklist of the free-living copepods of the Great Lakes. J. Great Lakes Res. 7, 382–393.

Hiltunen, J.K., Klemm, D.J. 1980. A guide to the Naididae (Annelida, Clitellata, Oligochaeta) of North America. Report EPA-600/4-80-0, U.S. EPA, Environmental Monitoring and Support Laboratory, Cincinnati, Ohio.

Hoffman, G. L. 1999. Parasites of North American freshwater fishes. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York.

Mackie, G.L., White, D.S., Zdeba, T.W. 1980. A guide to freshwater mollusks of the Laurentian Great Lakes, with special emphasis on the genus Pisidium. Report EPA/600/3-80-068, U.S. EPA, Environmental Research Laboratory, Duluth, Minnesota.

Some Ephemeroptera nymphs and Diptera larvae are common in the deep profundal benthic zones of the Great Lakes - other orders of aquatic insect larvae are restricted to littoral or tributary benthos, nearshore surface waters (e.g., water striders), or are parasitic on other Great Lakes waterlife (e.g., Lepidoptera and braconid wasps). Some Coleoptera and Hemiptera remain fully aquatic as adults (usually littoral) - other orders of aquatic insects have winged adults and are usually found floating on the water surface, associated with emergent macrophytes (e.g., wetlands) or in nearshore terrestrial habitats.

Nymphs and Larvae

Note on juvenile stages - Pupae are inactive stages (e.g., hard case, translucent case or cocoon). Larvae and nymphs are both active stages. Nymphs have rudimentary wings (or wing buds) and usually have jointed legs (usually 3 pair) similar to adults. Larvae lack rudimentary wings and usually lack legs or are limited to prolegs or projections (usually other than 3 pairs).

Larval mayfly - Hexagenia limbata
Ephemeroptera
(mayflies)

Nymph - 3 tail blades, lateral gills on abdomen

dragonfly nymph - Aeshna sp.
Odonata
(dragonflies & damselflies)

Nymph - 0-3 tail appendages, chewing mouth (predatory)

Chironomid larva
Diptera
(flies, midges & mosquitos)

Larvae - w/o legs

stonefly larvae - Acroneuria sp.
Plecoptera
(stoneflies)

Nymph - 2 tail appendages

Megaloptera larvae - Sialis sp.
Megaloptera
(alderflies & spongilliflies)

Alderfly larvae - with stout lateral processes on all segments
Spongillifly larvae - found in sponges with a slender curved mouth ~ half body length

Caddis fly larvae (bottom) and case (top)
Trichoptera
(caddisflies)

Larvae - found in cases, 1 pair of terminal prolegs with hooks

riffle beetle larvae - Stenelmis spp.
Coleoptera
(beetles)

Larvae - without prolegs or cases, usually 6 well developed thoracic legs but no wing pads

water strider nymphs - Gerris sp.
Hemiptera
(water bugs)

Nymphs - incomplete metamorphosis, juveniles look similar to adults

Bellura sp. larvae
Lepidoptera
(daggar and snout moths)

Larvae - caterpillars with 5 proleg pairs, usually parasitic in macrophytes rather than independently aquatic

braconid wasp larvae emerging from a caterpillar host
Hymenoptera
(braconid wasps)

Larvae - Parasitic on other larvae

Adults

Adult mayflies - Hexagenia limbata
Ephemeroptera
(mayflies)

Adult - 2-3 threadlike tails

Ischnura hastata - adult male damselfly
Odonata
(dragonflies & damselflies)

Adult - similarly sized fore and hindwings held perpendicular to the body (flat or vertical) at rest

Adult chironomus (midge)
Diptera
(flies, midges & mosquitos)

Adult - 1 pair of wings, no thread-like tails

Plecoptera adult - Alloperla sp.
Plecoptera
(stoneflies)

Adult - wings held flat and parallel to the body with hindwings fanfolded beneath the shorter forewings when at rest

Climaciaareolaris
Megaloptera
(alderflies and spongilliflies)

Adult - hind-wings broader than fore-wings at least at base, held downsloping at rest

adult caddisfly - Pneumatopsyche speciosa
Trichoptera
(caddisflies)

Adult - 2 pair of hairy wings held downsloping at rest

adult Hydaticus spp. - predaceous diving beetle
Coleoptera
(beetles)

Adult - forewings hardened to a protective covering meeting in a straight line down the back

adult water boatman - Sigara sp.
Hemiptera
(water bugs)

Adult - forewings meet leaving a triangular patch showing at the anterior portion of the back and are clear at the tips

Bellura sp. adult
Lepidoptera
(daggar and snout moths)

Adult - 2 pair of wings, both with powdery scales

adult braconid wasp
Hymenoptera
(braconid wasps)

Adult - extremely narrow waist

Ephemeroptera - Mayflies

Some Ephemeroptera nymphs are common in the deep profundal benthic zones of the Great Lakes - others are restricted to littoral or tributary benthos. Winged adults are usually found floating on the water surface, associated with emergent macrophytes (e.g., wetlands) or in nearshore terrestrial habitats. Ephemeroptera live most of their lives as nymphs with a very brief adult stage (mate and die). Mayflies are unique among insects in that they molt once as an 'adult' - thus having 2 winged stages. The subimago or dun is a shortlived stage usually at the water surface. The imago or spinner is the final form which participates in the mating flight. Adults usually lack a mouth and so are incapable of eating (or biting) and generally live less than 3 days after emergence. Ephemeroptera exhibit swarming behavior in which emergence (transformation of aquatic nymphs to flying adults) is strongly coincident (all the nymphs of the right age in an area transform within days of each other). Both nymphs and emergent adults are an important source of food for fish.

Fishermonk's Short Key to Mayfly Genera was consulted in the development of the Great Lakes keys on this page.

Key to Ephemeroptera Nymphs

Some Odonata (damselfly) nymphs are easily confused with Ephemeroptera (mayfly) nymphs.

Ephemeroptera Nymphs - Key to the 9 Great Lakes Families

Baetisca nymph line drawing
Baetiscidae
(armored mayflies)

dorsal surface of the thorax expanded (covering gills) into a broad shield - usually with points to the sides, extremely hump-backed

Tricorythodes nymph line drawing
Leptohyphidae
(Crawling Mayflies)

gills hidden (pair on the second segment modified to form a triangular cover)

Caenis line drawing
Caenidae
(Crawling Mayflies)

brown, gills hidden (pair on the second segment modified to form a square cover), legs sprawling

Ephemera line drawing
Ephemeridae
(Burrowing Mayflies)

Tusks. Visible gills on segments 2-7 each in 2 feathery branches held vertically over the back.

Ephemerella line drawing
Ephemerellidae

4 visible pairs of gills (no gills on segment 2, usually none on 1 or 3, 5th pair small and hidden beneath 4th) - not held dorsally. Each gill a flat plate.

Mayfly - Heptagenia drawing Heptageniidae
(Clinging Mayflies - Two-Tailed Mayflies)

Head and body both flattened. Large dorsal eyes. 7 pairs of gills each consisting of 1 flat plate with a tuft. Legs sprawling

Mayfly - Baetis Nymph drawing
Baetidae
(Swimming Mayflies)

greenish, <10mm, gills in 1-2 oval or heart-shaped plates. Abdomen without spines. Tails fringed with setae along the length (on the two external tails, fringes toward the inside only). Legs ventral rather than to the side (swimmers).

Mayfly - Paraleptophlebia drawing
Leptophlebiidae

7 pairs of gills. Each Gill forms 2 straps or a tapering plate or a small base with radiating filaments. Tails equal to or longer than body and each with hairs at the end (not a fringe along the length). Legs ventral rather than to the side (swimmers).

Oligoneuridae line drawing
Oligoneuridae
(Torpedo Mayflies or
Coachmen Nymphs )

Gills of the 1st segment on the bottom of the segment. Gills flat with tufts. long slender hairs on the inside of the front legs. No tusks. tails with dense fringe on inside edges.

Ephemeridae nymphs - Key to the 3 Great Lakes Genera

Close-up: Ephoron head.  Photo Courtesy of Dr. H. Arndt

Ephoron

mandibular tusks have spines on the top surface and are not curved upward

Close-up: Ephemera head.  Photo Courtesy of Jason Neuswanger
Ephemera

Frontal prominence of head deeply forked

Close-up: Hexagenia limbata head.  Photo Courtesy of Jason Neuswanger
Hexagenia

Frontal prominence of head rounded; Mandibular tusks long and upcurved, with tips divergent

Ephemerellidae nymphs - Key to the 2 Great Lakes Genera

Close-up: Ephermerella abdomen.  Original photo courtesy of The Kinnickinnic River Land Trust
Ephemerella

Sides of abdominal segment 9 don't extended to the tails

Close-up: Eurylophella abdomen.  Original photo Courtesy of Electronic Field Guide to Aquatic Invertebrates
Eurylophella

Abdominal segment 9 longer than 8

Heptageniidae nymphs - Key to the 3 Great Lakes Genera

Heptagenia sp.
Heptagenia

Gills of all segments platelike

Stenonema vicarium
Stenonema

Gills of abdominal segment 7 slender, fingerlike Strong dark/light color pattern on body

Stenacron sp.
Stenacron Key NA

Baetidae nymphs - Key to the 5 Great Lakes Genera

Closeup: Ameletus Abdomen
Ameletus

Double-strap shaped gills, 3 equal tails

Closeup: Baetis abdomen
Baetis

Single plate-like gills, hindwing pad present, very short middle tail

Callibaetis sp.
Callibaetis

Double heart-shaped gills, hindwing pad present,

Close-up: Centroptilum abdomen
Centropilum

Single plate-like gills, hindwing pad present, 3 equal tails

Pseudocloeon

Single plate-like gills, no hindwing pad, only 2 tails

Leptophlebidae nymphs - Key to the 2 Great Lakes Genera

Closeup: Leptophlebia abdomen.  Original Photo Courtesy of Jason Neuswanger
Leptophlebia

Only gills on segment 1 deeply cleft appearing as 2 straps

Closeup: Paraleptophlebia abdomen.  Original Photo Courtesy of Jason Neuswanger
Paraleptophlebia

All gills deeply cleft appearing as 2 straps

Key to Adult (Imago/Subimago) Ephemeroptera

Ephemeroptera Adults - Key to Great Lakes Families

Typical keys to the adult (imago/subimago) forms of mayflies rely heavily on patterns of veins in the forewings for identification. A good hand lens is a necessity for proper identification.

Baetiscidae

Body: 6-9mm. Thorax unusually large (stout) & abdomen tapers sharply in its rear half (Abdominal segments 6 and 7 wider, longer, and higher in profile view than segments 5 and 8).

Tail: 2-3, 3rd (middle) tail is very short or absent

Wings: Hindwings variable, may be reduced or absent, if present almost circular in shape.

Venation: Vein MP2 not bent, not parallel with CuA near wing base, from vein MP1; vein MP2 only may diverge from MP1. Cubital intercalaries absent with vein A1 terminating in outer margin of wings.

Leptohyphidae
(Tricorythodes)

Color: Black insect with white wings - thorax may actually be blackish, dark grey or dark brown.

Body: <4mm. Bodies have a heavy thorax

Tails: 3

Wings: hindwings absent. Forewings longer in relation to width than Caenidae

Venation: Vein MA forming a more or less symmetrical fork, and veins MP2 and IMP extend less than three-fourths of distance to base of vein MP.

Caenidae

Color: Wings whitish. Thorax usually brown.

Body: <4mm. Robust thorax, small abdomen

Tails: 3

Wings: hindwings absent. Forewings shorter in relation to width than Leptohyphidae

Venation: MA2 attached basally by a crossvein, and veins MP2 and IMP almost as long as vein MP extending nearly to base.

Ephemera forewing veins - Inset, relative size of hindwings
Ephemeridae

Color: Abdomen of most species with striking dark pattern - except Ephoron which is yellow shaded with tan.

Body: 12-40mm.

Tails: 2-3

Wing: Hindwings present. Costal angulation of hindwings usually rounded, but may be nearly acute or at right angles

Venation: Base of vein MP2 sharply bent near the wing base towards CuA and sometimes fused at base with CuA. Vein A1 forked near margin and outer margin with dense network of reticulate veinlets (Ephoron) OR vein A1 unforked, attached to hind margin by three or more veinlets.

Ephemerellidae

Body: 4-15mm.

Tails: 3

Wings: Hind wings usually large, with a pronounced angle on the fore margin. Costal projection shorter than wing width.

Venation: Vein MP2 not bent, not parallel with CuA near wing base; vein MP2 only may diverge from MP1. One or two long intercalary veins between MP2 and CuA. Cubital intercalaries variable, but not as a series of veinlets or attaching vein CuA to hind margin. Short, basally detached marginal intercalaries present between veins along entire outer margin of wings.

Heptageniidae

Body:4-20mm.

Tails: 2

Wings:Hindwings large

Venation: Vein MP2 not bent, not parallel with CuA near wing base; vein MP2 only may diverge from MP1. MA2 and MP2 attached basally. 2 pairs of cubital intercalaries present with vein A1 terminating in hind margin of wings.

Baetidae

Body: 4-20mm. Abdominal segments ~ equal.

Tails: 2

Wings: Hind wings <1/2 long as forewings or absent. Costal projection of hindwings acute.

Venation: Vein MP2 not bent, not parallel with CuA near wing base. Veins MA2 and MP2 may be detached basally from their respective sterns. Cubital intercalaries (A) consist of a series of veinlets, often forking or sinuate, attaching vein CuA to hind margin OR (B) with vein A1 terminating in hind margin of wings OR (C) absent. Short, basally detached, single or double marginal intercalaries may be present in each interspace.

Leptophlebiidae

Body: 4-12mm.

Tails: 3

Wings: Hind wings present and usually relatively large but without a pronounced angle on the fore margin. Costal projection shorter than wing width.

Venation: Vein MP2 not bent, not parallel with CuA near wing base; vein MP2 only may diverge from MP1. 1-2 pair of cubital intercalaries, but not attaching vein CuA to hind margin nor two pairs in which the anterior pair is long and the posterior pair very short nor Vein A-I attached to hind margin. True basally detached marginal intercalaries usually absent along entire outer margin of wings.

Oligoneuridae

Body: 9-17mm, dark

Forewing venation greatly reduced, apparently only three or four longitudinal veins behind R1.

Ephemeridae Adults - Key to Great Lakes Genera

Ephoron sp. adult
Ephoron

11-13mm, legs feeble, mostly non-functional. Wings often somewhat translucent and colorless or with gray or purplish gray shading.

Ephemera vulgata imago
Ephemera

15-20mm, legs functional; spotted wings; 3 tails of equal length

Hexagenia limbata adult
Hexagenia

30-40mm, legs functional; wings hyaline without spots, 2 tails (or middle very short), body yellow-light brown and patterned.

Ephemerellidae Adults - Key to Great Lakes Genera

Ephemerella ignita
Ephemerella

3 tails of equal length

Eurylophella

NA

Heptageniidae Adults - Key to Great Lakes Genera

Heptagenia sp. adult
Heptagenia

4-12mm, Wings may have crossveins below bullae clouded, but not dark. Basal crossveins between R1 and R2 rarely margined. Penes not L-shaped

Stenonema vicarium adult male
Stenonema

6-20mm, Wings may have crossveins below bullae clouded, but not dark. Basal crossveins between R1 and R2 rarely margined. Penes more or less L-shaped

Stenacron sp. subimago
Stenacron

~13mm, Wings with 2-3 crossveins below bullae between veins R1 and R2 connected or nearly connected by dark pigmentation, rarely only a dark spot. Basal crossveins between R1 and R2 dark margined.

Baetidae Adults - Key to Great Lakes Genera

Ameletus sp. subimago
Ameletus

9mm.
Hindwings small with a sharp or pointed costal angulation.

Cubital intercalaries of forewing consist of a series of veinlets, often forking or sinuate, attaching vein CuA to hind margin.

Baetis rhodani imago
Baetis

4-10mm.
Hindwings small with a pointed costal angulation.

Both fore and hind wings with few crossveins.

Marginal veinlets of forewing in pairs.

Callibaetis subimago
Callibaetis

Hindwings minute with an obtuse costal angulation.

Both fore and hind wings with numerous crossveins.

Body appears freckled.

Centroptilum luteolum subimago
Centropilum

Hindwings small w/hooked costal angulation.

Both fore and hind wings with few crossveins;

Marginal veinlets of forewing single.

Pseudocloeon

4-6mm. No hindwings

Leptophlebidae Adults - Key to Great Lakes Genera

Leptophlebia cupida A
Leptophlebia

10-12 mm; body robust; the middle tail is shorter and thinner than the outer ones.

Paraleptophlebia submarginata imago
Paraleptophlebia

4-8 mm; body slender; 3 tails about equal in length and thickness. Brown or pale in color.

Keys to Odonata Nymphs

Note on juvenile stages - Nymphs are active stages. Nymphs have rudimentary wings (or wing buds) and usually have jointed legs (usually 3 pair) similar to adults. Nymphs are most easily identified to species when individuals are mature (late instar).

Odonata Nymphs - Key to the Suborders

Leucorrhinia intacta

Gills in the posterior digestive tract.

Suborder Anisoptera
(Dragonfly nymphs)

Lestidae

Gills consist of 3 flat external plates at the posterior end.

Suborder Zygoptera
(Damselfly nymphs)

Odonata Adults - Key to the Suborders

Leucorrhinia hudsonica

Stout build, Strong sustained flight. Wings held flat when perched.

Anisoptera
Dragonflies

Calopteryx maculata

Slight build. Weak, fluttery flight. Wings held over back when perched (except spreadwings)

Zygoptera
Damselflies